Published by The Weingart Firm, PLLC. Mark N. Weingart, board-certified criminal law specialist.
It is close to midnight on the Loop 202 in Tempe. You were pulled over, did a few field sobriety tests, and are now in the back of a patrol car. At the station, an officer reads you a form and asks whether you will take a breath test. You are nervous, unsure what the right answer is, and you say nothing or say no.
Many people make that choice in a few seconds, without knowing that the refusal starts its own legal process. It runs separately from the DUI charge, which is why an Arizona DUI defense lawyer looks at both. So what happens if you refuse a breath or blood test in Arizona?
Q: What happens if you refuse a breath or blood test in Arizona?
A: Under A.R.S. 28-1321, refusing a breath or blood test after a DUI arrest leads to an MVD suspension of 12 months, or two years for a second or subsequent refusal within 84 months. Police can still seek a search warrant to draw your blood, and the refusal can be used as evidence in your criminal case. Your hearing request must be received by MVD within 30 days after the date of the suspension notice.
Refused a breath or blood test after a DUI arrest? You have only 30 days to request the MVD hearing, and that hearing can shape the criminal case. Our DUI defense team can review the stop, the refusal, and any warrant blood draw. Call 480-897-8737 for a free consultation.
This guide focuses on the refusal itself. It explains how Arizona’s implied consent law works, what counts as a refusal, why police can often get your blood anyway, how the refusal suspension differs from the admin per se suspension, what the MVD hearing can and cannot decide, and whether you can drive during the suspension. It ends with practical steps to take in the first days after a refusal.
In this article:
- What Is Arizona’s Implied Consent Law?
- What Counts as a Refusal in Arizona?
- Can Police Still Get Your Blood After You Refuse?
- How Is a Refusal Suspension Different From an Admin Per Se Suspension?
- How Do You Challenge a Refusal Suspension at the MVD?
- Can You Drive During a Refusal Suspension?
- Does Refusing Help or Hurt the Criminal DUI Case?
- What Should You Do After Refusing a Test in Arizona?
What Is Arizona’s Implied Consent Law?
Arizona’s implied consent law says that anyone who drives a motor vehicle in the state has already agreed to chemical testing if they are arrested for DUI. The rule is in A.R.S. 28-1321. The consent covers tests of your blood, breath, urine, or other bodily substance to measure alcohol concentration or drug content.
A few details in the statute matter in real cases:
- The agency chooses the test. The test or tests are the ones chosen by the law enforcement agency, given at the direction of an officer who has reasonable grounds to believe you were driving or in actual physical control of a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, or, if you are under 21, with alcohol in your body.
- It applies after an arrest. The request to test under this implied consent procedure comes after you have been placed under arrest, not during the first moments of a traffic stop. Separate rules can allow police to obtain blood evidence without an arrest.
- You must be told the consequences. The officer must inform you that refusing will lead to a license suspension.
- Unconscious drivers are covered. A person who is unconscious or otherwise unable to refuse is treated by the statute as not having withdrawn consent. But that provision alone does not authorize a warrantless blood draw: police still need a warrant or a constitutionally valid exception to the warrant requirement, such as exigent circumstances.
Implied consent does not mean you are physically forced to blow into a machine. It means that saying no has consequences that the law sets in advance, mainly through the MVD.
What Counts as a Refusal in Arizona?
A refusal is not limited to saying the word “no.” Under A.R.S. 28-1321, a failure to expressly agree to the test, or a failure to successfully complete it, is treated as a refusal. That is a broad standard, and it catches situations many drivers do not expect.
Examples of conduct that officers can report as a refusal include:
- Staying silent after being asked to test, since silence is not an express agreement.
- Conditional answers such as “only if I can pick the test,” depending on the circumstances. Asking to talk to a lawyer, standing alone, is not a refusal if consulting counsel does not hinder the investigation.
- Not completing a breath test, for example, by not providing adequate samples. A “deficient sample” reading alone does not automatically establish a refusal; the circumstances and evidence of unsuccessful completion matter.
- Refusing and then changing your mind after a search warrant for a blood sample has been issued. Merely recording a refusal does not necessarily prevent a driver from effectively withdrawing it before that point; the timing and circumstances matter.
Whether a refusal really happened is often a fact question. What the officer asked, how you answered, whether you understood the request, and whether a medical issue or language barrier played a role can all matter. Body camera and station video are usually the best evidence of what was actually said.
The officer must also sign a certified report describing the manner of the refusal, and that report is made under penalty of perjury, so its details can be compared against the video.
Can Police Still Get Your Blood After You Refuse?
Yes. Refusing does not guarantee that no test will happen. Under A.R.S. 28-1321, once you refuse, police may not take your blood unless they obtain a search warrant or the medical-sample exception applies. Officers can request a warrant by telephone or other electronic means, and a blood draw may follow within the same night.
A separate path also exists for blood taken for medical reasons. Under A.R.S. 28-1388, if an officer has probable cause to believe a person committed DUI and blood or another sample was taken from that person for any reason, such as treatment at a hospital after a crash, the statute requires a portion of that sample to be provided to law enforcement on request.
But the statute does not eliminate constitutional protections. To obtain a medical blood sample without a warrant under this exception, the state must also establish that exigent circumstances made obtaining a warrant impractical, that medical personnel drew the blood for a medical reason, and that the treatment did not violate the person’s right to direct their own medical care. That generally requires voluntary consent to treatment or an inability to consent, such as unconsciousness or delirium.
This means a refusal can leave you with the worst of both outcomes: a refusal suspension from the MVD and a blood result that the state uses in court. It also means the defense review does not stop at the refusal. How the warrant was obtained, what the affidavit said, and how the blood was drawn and tested can all be examined. Our guide to challenging blood test evidence after a DUI arrest covers that side of the case in more detail.
How Is a Refusal Suspension Different From an Admin Per Se Suspension?
A refusal suspension under A.R.S. 28-1321 is longer and more rigid than the administrative per se suspension that applies when testing establishes a qualifying alcohol concentration or drug result. The per se suspension is governed by A.R.S. 28-1385.
It is triggered by a result of 0.08 or more, 0.04 or more in a commercial vehicle, a vehicle for hire, or while providing transportation network services as a transportation network company driver, or a drug defined in Arizona’s controlled-substance law or its metabolite in your body unless you possess a valid prescription for the drug. The administrative process can begin while test results are still pending, and the sample need not have been obtained with your consent.
Under 28-1385, the suspension is at least 90 consecutive days, and some eligible drivers qualify to serve at least 30 days followed by at least 60 days of restricted driving, or to obtain a special ignition interlock restricted driver license instead. Eligibility for the 30-day and 60-day option depends on the absence of a qualifying conviction within 84 months, no death or serious physical injury to another person arising from the incident, and completion of required screening.
Under 28-1321, the refusal suspension is 12 months, or two years if it is a second or subsequent refusal within 84 months. The hearing issues are different too. A per se hearing can examine whether the test method was valid and reliable and whether the results were evaluated accurately. A refusal hearing does not decide whether a test result proves you were impaired or over a legal limit; it focuses on reasonable grounds, arrest, refusal, and the required warning.
| Issue | Refusal suspension (A.R.S. 28-1321) | Test failure suspension (A.R.S. 28-1385) |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Refusing or not completing a test after a DUI arrest | Result of 0.08 or more; 0.04 or more in a commercial vehicle, a vehicle for hire, or while providing transportation network services; or a drug defined in Arizona’s controlled-substance law or its metabolite without a valid prescription for the drug. The process can begin while results are pending. |
| Length | 12 months; 2 years for a second or subsequent refusal within 84 months | At least 90 consecutive days; eligible drivers may serve at least 30 days plus at least 60 days restricted, or obtain a special ignition interlock restricted driver license instead |
| Hearing request deadline | Received by MVD within 30 days after the date of the notice | Received by MVD within 30 days after the date of the notice |
| Main hearing issues | Reasonable grounds, arrest, refusal, warning of consequences | Reasonable grounds, arrest, test result, validity and reliability of the testing method, and accurate evaluation of the results |
| Special interlock license | Available for a first refusal after required screening and satisfaction of applicable eligibility requirements; the first-refusal provision does not apply to a second or subsequent refusal within 84 months | May be available if eligibility requirements are met |
If you want a broader picture of every way your license can be affected after an arrest, including suspensions that follow a conviction, see how DUI license suspensions work in Arizona.
How Do You Challenge a Refusal Suspension at the MVD?
You request a hearing, and you have 30 days to do it. Under A.R.S. 28-1321, the MVD must receive your written or online hearing request within thirty days after the date of the notice. If no timely request is filed, an order served by an officer takes effect thirty days after service; if MVD mails the notice, the suspension takes effect thirty days after the notice is issued. Your hearing request will not be accepted unless you surrender any Arizona driver license or permit, or certify that it is lost or destroyed.
A timely request stays the suspension until the hearing is held. The MVD does not return a surrendered license while the request is pending, but it may issue temporary permits to drive. If you surrender a valid license or permit, the officer must issue a temporary driving permit valid for thirty days.
Read your paperwork closely and confirm the permit’s expiration date and whether MVD has issued an extension while the hearing is pending. Our post on the documents you receive after a DUI arrest walks through those forms.
The hearing itself is narrow. It is limited to four issues:
- Reasonable grounds. Whether the officer had reasonable grounds to believe you were driving or in actual physical control of a vehicle while under the influence (or, for a driver under 21, with spirituous liquor in your body).
- Arrest. Whether you were placed under arrest.
- Refusal. Whether you refused to submit to the test.
- Warning. Whether you were informed of the consequences of refusing.
Guilt or innocence on the DUI charge is not an issue at this hearing. The hearing officer is not deciding whether you were impaired, only whether the officer had reasonable grounds and whether the refusal process was followed.
Even so, the hearing can be valuable. If the state cannot prove one of the four issues, the suspension should not be upheld. The hearing is also a chance to question the arresting officer under oath, and that testimony can later be compared with what the officer says in the criminal case. The full administrative process is covered on our Arizona MVD process page.
Can You Drive During a Refusal Suspension?
Some drivers can, with an ignition interlock. Under A.R.S. 28-1321, after completing any alcohol or other drug screening ordered by the MVD, a person suspended for refusal may apply for a special ignition interlock restricted driver license under A.R.S. 28-1401, if the applicable eligibility requirements are met. That license allows driving during the suspension, subject to the interlock requirements.
Key limits apply:
- First refusal only under the ordinary eligibility route. The provision allowing an application after screening does not apply to a second or subsequent refusal within 84 months. The ordinary route under A.R.S. 28-1401 applies to class D or class G licenses and offenses involving only alcohol, or a combination of drugs and alcohol with an alcohol concentration of at least 0.08.
- Interlock for the rest of the suspension. You must keep a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the remainder of the suspension, and the MVD can extend the interlock period in some situations.
- Screening is required. Your license can be reinstated after the suspension only if you complete alcohol or other drug screening.
A.R.S. 28-1321 also provides a separate discretionary route under which MVD may issue a special ignition interlock restricted driver license notwithstanding A.R.S. 28-1401. If MVD issues a license under that route, you agree to the administrative action and waive your right to an administrative hearing challenging it under the refusal or admin per se statutes. Discuss eligibility and that waiver before applying.
Driving without a valid permit or restricted license while suspended can lead to new charges and a much more serious case, so it is worth waiting until your paperwork is in order.
Does Refusing Help or Hurt the Criminal DUI Case?
It can cut both ways. Under A.R.S. 28-1388, evidence of refusal is admissible in any civil or criminal proceeding, whether or not a sample was later collected by warrant. A prosecutor can argue to a jury that you refused because you expected to fail. The refusal does not by itself prove impairment, and there are often innocent explanations for how the exchange went.
If no test result exists, the state may have to prove impairment “to the slightest degree” under A.R.S. 28-1381 using driving behavior, field sobriety tests, officer observations, and video. Those cases turn on the quality of that evidence.
If an officer draws blood with a warrant, the case may look much like any other blood test case, with the refusal added as another piece of evidence. Either way, the refusal suspension and the criminal case proceed on separate tracks, and the outcome of one does not automatically decide the other.
What Should You Do After Refusing a Test in Arizona?
The first days after a refusal matter more than most people realize. These steps help protect your options:
- Find the date on your notice. Locate the suspension notice and identify the 30-day deadline to request a hearing. If an officer served the order, use the date shown on that order; if MVD mailed the notice, do not count from the day you received it. Put the deadline on your calendar.
- Request the MVD hearing on time. MVD must receive the request within the deadline; merely mailing it by then is not enough. Surrender any Arizona driver license or permit, or certify that it is lost or destroyed, as required for acceptance of the request. A timely request stays the suspension and preserves your right to challenge the four hearing issues, unless you have waived that right by obtaining a special interlock license under the discretionary route described above.
- Write down what happened. Note what the officer asked, what you said, whether you asked for a lawyer, and any medical or language issues, while your memory is fresh.
- Ask about a blood draw. If blood was taken by warrant or at a hospital, make a note of where and when. Results often take weeks.
- Do not drive on a suspended license. Wait until you have a valid temporary permit or restricted license.
- Talk to a DUI defense lawyer early. The refusal hearing and the criminal case should be planned together, since testimony in one can affect the other.
A refusal is not the end of the case. It changes which issues matter, and it puts a short deadline in front of you.
Facing a refusal suspension and a DUI charge? The MVD hearing and the criminal case run on separate tracks, but decisions in one can affect the other. Mark N. Weingart is a former Tempe judge, former prosecutor, and Arizona board-certified criminal law specialist. Call 480-897-8737 for a free consultation.
