Published by The Weingart Firm, PLLC. Mark N. Weingart, board-certified criminal law specialist.
The penalty for theft in Arizona usually depends on the value of the property or services involved, but some items and circumstances make the charge a felony regardless of value. Where the felony line falls matters, because a felony conviction carries far harsher consequences.
The claimed value is often the first thing an Arizona theft defense lawyer examines. So when does theft become a felony in Arizona?
Q: When does theft become a felony in Arizona?
A: Theft of property or services worth $1,000 or more is a felony in Arizona, starting as a class 6 felony and rising to a class 2 felony at $25,000 or more. Theft of property taken from the person of another, a firearm, or an animal taken for fighting is a felony even below $1,000, and theft of a vehicle engine or transmission is a class 4 felony regardless of value.
Charged with felony theft? A dispute over value can be the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor. Our theft defense team reviews how the State calculated the value and what it can prove. Call 480-897-8737 for a free consultation.
This guide explains what counts as theft in Arizona, the value thresholds for each felony class, which thefts are felonies regardless of value, how value is proven, and the defenses that may apply.
In this article:
- What Is Considered Theft Under Arizona Law?
- What Are the Value Thresholds for Felony Theft?
- When Is Theft a Felony Regardless of Value?
- How Is the Value of Stolen Property Determined?
- What Penalties Can a Theft Conviction Bring?
- Can a Felony Theft Charge Be Reduced to a Misdemeanor?
- Do You Have to Pay Restitution for a Theft Conviction?
- What Defenses Are Available in a Theft Case?
- What Should You Do After a Theft Charge?
What Is Considered Theft Under Arizona Law?
Under A.R.S. 13-1802, a person commits theft by knowingly, without lawful authority:
- Controlling another person’s property with the intent to deprive the owner of it
- Converting property or services entrusted to them for a limited use to an unauthorized term or use
- Obtaining property or services by a material misrepresentation with the intent to deprive the owner of them
- Appropriating lost, mislaid, or misdelivered property without reasonable efforts to notify the owner when the circumstances provide a means of identifying the owner
- Controlling property knowing or having reason to know it was stolen
- Obtaining services known to require compensation without paying or agreeing to pay, or diverting another’s services without authority
The statute also addresses theft of metal and theft of a vulnerable adult’s property by someone acting in a position of trust and confidence with the intent to deprive the adult of it.
Those categories cover embezzlement, theft by deception, possession of stolen property, and theft of services. Related offenses, such as shoplifting under its own statute, may be charged separately and have different classification rules.
What Are the Value Thresholds for Felony Theft?
Arizona generally grades theft under A.R.S. 13-1802 by the value of the property or services taken, subject to the exceptions discussed below:
| Value of property or services | Classification |
|---|---|
| Less than $1,000 | Class 1 misdemeanor, unless a felony exception applies |
| $1,000 to less than $2,000 | Class 6 felony |
| $2,000 to less than $3,000 | Class 5 felony |
| $3,000 to less than $4,000 | Class 4 felony |
| $4,000 to less than $25,000 | Class 3 felony |
| $25,000 or more | Class 2 felony |
A conviction under A.R.S. 13-1802(A)(1) or (A)(3) involving property worth $100,000 or more bars probation and suspension of sentence and restricts release from confinement, subject to the statutory exceptions. Our overview of felony crimes and penalties in Arizona explains what each felony class can mean.
When Is Theft a Felony Regardless of Value?
Some thefts are felonies no matter what the item is worth:
| Item stolen | Classification regardless of value |
|---|---|
| Firearm | Class 6 felony if worth less than $2,000; higher value-based classifications apply at $2,000 or more |
| Animal taken for the purpose of animal fighting | Class 6 felony if worth less than $2,000; higher value-based classifications apply at $2,000 or more |
| Vehicle engine or transmission | Class 4 felony |
Theft of property taken from the person of another is also a felony regardless of value. It is a class 6 felony below $2,000, with higher value-based classifications applying at $2,000 or more.
Other statutes can also raise the stakes, including separate offenses for vehicle theft and organized retail theft, and sentencing enhancements for people with prior convictions. The specific charge and your history should be reviewed carefully.
How Is the Value of Stolen Property Determined?
Because the value generally sets the felony class, it is often the most important fact in a theft case. Under A.R.S. 13-1801, value generally means fair market value at the time of the theft, and the State must prove the value needed for the charged classification.
Disputes can involve retail price versus actual market value, the condition of used items, and whether separate incidents were properly combined. The State may combine amounts taken in thefts committed as part of one scheme or course of conduct.
Recovering stolen property does not by itself reduce its value at the time of the theft. For metal theft, the valuation rules include the repair or replacement value of property from which the metal was removed and damage caused during the theft. A shift of a few hundred dollars can move a case from felony to misdemeanor when no felony exception applies.
What Penalties Can a Theft Conviction Bring?
A misdemeanor theft can bring jail, probation, fines, and restitution. A felony theft can bring prison exposure that increases with the felony class and any prior convictions, along with restitution to the victim and a felony record.
A felony can affect employment, housing, professional licensing, and firearm rights. Later, relief may be available through a set-aside or record sealing, depending on eligibility. A set-aside does not erase the conviction, and sealing has exceptions and disclosure requirements; our article on set-aside and sealing in Arizona explains how those options work.
Can a Felony Theft Charge Be Reduced to a Misdemeanor?
Sometimes. Challenging the value can bring the charge below $1,000 if no felony exception applies, and Arizona also allows some class 6 felonies to be designated as misdemeanors under A.R.S. 13-604, depending on the facts and your history. That provision applies to nondangerous class 6 felonies and excludes people with two or more prior felony convictions.
Do You Have to Pay Restitution for a Theft Conviction?
Generally, yes. Arizona courts order restitution to victims for their economic losses as part of the sentence.
What Defenses Are Available in a Theft Case?
The defenses depend on the facts, but common issues include the following:
- Lack of the required mental state. The State must prove the knowledge and any specific intent required by the charged form of theft, and an honest mistake or misunderstanding may defeat that proof.
- Mistaken identity. Surveillance footage and eyewitness identifications can be unreliable.
- Claim of right. A lawful right to control the property can defeat the charge, but an ownership interest alone does not necessarily do so if another person also has an interest that you are not entitled to infringe.
- Value disputes. Challenging the claimed value can reduce the felony class or bring the case to a misdemeanor when no felony exception applies.
- Insufficient evidence. The prosecution must prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt.
- Constitutional violations. Evidence from an unlawful search or statements taken improperly may be suppressed.
See whether police can search your car without a warrant and whether you should talk to police after an arrest. Theft allegations sometimes arise alongside other charges, such as resisting arrest.
What Should You Do After a Theft Charge?
Do not discuss the allegation with store security, the alleged victim, or police without legal advice, and do not contact witnesses. Keep receipts, bank records, messages, and anything else that shows ownership, permission, or value.
Surveillance video is often overwritten on a set schedule, so it should be identified early. If your case is in Phoenix, learn about our Phoenix theft defense work.
Facing a theft charge in Tempe, Phoenix, or elsewhere in Maricopa County? Surveillance video and value records should be reviewed early. Mark N. Weingart is a former Tempe judge, former prosecutor, and Arizona board-certified criminal law specialist. Call 480-897-8737 for a free consultation.
